Our analyst Tyrone spent all last week reviewing our Partner client data for Q3 and discovered a few insights and recommendations we’re bringing to all our client work, particularly around podcasts and social media.
AI is massively disrupting the marketing industry, so we’re staying on top of what’s working, what’s not, and what tools can help us improve our clients’ goals. At the end of the day, however, we’re finding that marketing is still marketing: You need a great story built by and for people.
Here’s what we learned.
1. Consider your podcast as a YouTube show.
For every client we reviewed, YouTube views outnumbered audio downloads—often by a wide margin. On one show, 96% of the all-time audience came through YouTube. On another, a single episode drew about 1,500 YouTube views and roughly 30 audio downloads.
The audio audience is real and loyal. On one show it grew even as YouTube dipped. It just isn’t where most people find you.
So, here’s what we’re improving: Treat YouTube as the front door. Write every title and thumbnail for someone scrolling who has never heard of you.
2. Write specific titles.
The clearest pattern across the portfolio was in episode titles. Titles that named something specific—a concept people search for, a decision they face, an audience they belong to—beat titles built on a mood or a metaphor.
On one channel, a plain how-to title with a concrete payoff reached about 20,000 views. A vague, insider-sounding title on the same channel got about 200. “Navigating” titles, storm metaphors, and clever phrases with no searchable term underperformed everywhere. Guest names helped only when the guest was already well known.
Here’s what we’re improving: We’re looking at improving titles toward a formula like [Named concept]: [concrete payoff] for [audience]. If a stranger can’t tell what the episode is about from the title alone, rewrite it.
3. Vary thumbnails.
Three channels used a template where every episode looked nearly identical—same background, same layout, the title repeated in small type. In a feed, nothing could really distinguish one episode from the next.
One channel’s earliest episodes all shared the same thumbnail and average about five views each. Its newest template, with large faces and short text, has a median near 100. On another channel, stock-image thumbnails made up most of the bottom ten, while every thumbnail with a real person landed near or above the median. Episode age and topic muddy the comparison, but the direction is consistent.
Here’s what we’re improving: We’re using a three- to six-word hook on the thumbnail, not the full title. Big faces, a visible emotion, and one cue for what makes this episode different.
4. Treat every episode as a campaign.
One of our clients recently told us to “treat every send as a campaign,” meaning what we produce should have a clear, niched audience, with an obvious CTA and offer for that particular audience.
Social posts on their own moved listening less than we expected. One of the year’s strongest episodes had promotional posts with zero likes. Instead, the audience found it through search inside YouTube and podcast apps.
What moved people was deliberate distribution. One guest episode, launched with a dedicated email and a LinkedIn push, drove 80% of the website visits that client’s podcast produced all quarter. Posts that tagged the guest, their community, and partner brands drew the most engagement we saw.
We’re also big fans of what’s known as “employee advocacy,” where we promote the content across the leadership team’s LinkedIn profiles, not just the company profile.
Here’s what we’re improving: Give every guest episode a launch—an email, a personal LinkedIn post, and tags for everyone involved.
5. Add UTM links to every YouTube description.
Views are growing, but often visits and leads don’t hold the same pace. On one account, episodes with 300 to 1,500 YouTube views sent zero to six people to the website and produced no form fills. Across three clients, nearly half of all leads still landed on the homepage rather than on the content that earned them.
That tells us that the content is interesting and useful, but the conversion path to the website isn’t as clear. Most video descriptions carried no tracked link, and, as the previous point mentioned, most episode pages offered no clear next step.
6. Take the people. Leave the bots.
This was the most AI-direct finding. Four clients had bot traffic distorting their analytics—one-day spikes up to ten times normal volume, whole countries sending visits with zero seconds of engagement, and in one case a referral from a site that sells traffic. One client’s apparent drop in traffic turned out to be mostly bots leaving.
The strangest case was a one-hour burst of branded searches landing on a client’s homepage and the team page. Real people? An AI agent researching the firm? We still can’t tell, which is kind of the point. More of the “visitors” sizing up your company may be machines working on someone’s behalf.
Here’s what we’re improving: Report on engaged sessions only, apply one bot filter everywhere, and use Search Console as the honest check on organic traffic. We’re looking into spinning up Cloudflare bot filters across our portfolio.
7. Focus on clicks, not just impressions.
Search visibility improved for most clients this quarter. One saw impressions rise about 40% in three months. Another’s average position climbed from 11 to 8. But clicks didn’t always follow. One page earned more than 22,000 impressions with a click-through rate under 0.3%. Google was showing it, but people were scrolling right past.
Organic search is still doing its job: For one client, half of all leads came from Google. We just have to be clearer about how to present information so people using Google can find what they’re looking for. Not rocket science, but every detail counts.
Here’s what we’re improving: We’ll be scanning the highest-impression, lowest-click pages to rewrite their titles and descriptions.
The lesson? Be specific, findable, and trustworthy.
Under all seven lessons sits one larger shift. AI is changing both sides of the screen: People increasingly find content by searching inside platforms rather than scrolling feeds, and a growing share of what we measure may not be people at all.
Both point to the same response: Be specific, be findable, and build the kind of trust that holds up when a person, or their agent, comes looking. We still believe a podcast is the most cost-effective marketing available. Dollar for dollar, it makes your company’s marketing effective, consistent, and systematic, as we’ve been saying for years.
What will help with this is developing theses for our Partner clients now that we have a quarter’s worth of hard data. That’s another topic for another day.